Cover Up…

So I was puttering around on Goodreads and came across this

THEY REBRANDED THE CAT WHO… SERIES AS “JIM QWILLERAN FELINE WHODUNIT”

The Cat Who series is probably the most classic cozy mystery series (actually, I’d put it first, but Agatha Christie is the pinnacle of cozy mystery, so I’ll compromise and put the Cat Who series as second.). This series originally came out in the 60s before the author brought it back a few decades later and that’s when I started reading it. It’s THE cozy mystery series in my mind but this travesty is even worse than that horribly ignoble last book in the series. First, they renamed the series, -it’s understandable in that a revamp would bring in new readers but it’s entirely unnecessary. It would be like renaming Hamlet to “Yo, BRUH!” so that modern readers will discover it. Preposterous, isn’t it? And if that’s not unforgivable enough, they put a black cat on the covers and Koko and Yum Yum are Siamese cats. Ugh.

So I brought my outrage to the r/CozyMystery Discord server and ended up in a discussion about how Cozy Mystery covers are losing their coziness, getting away from the beautifully drawn covers and getting into covers that look like a photoshop collage. And that makes me sad!

31187826. sy475

Look at this book cover from a few years ago. Now this is a quintessentially Cozy Mystery cover. I mean, look at it! The cover screams cozy – the adorable cat, the detailed drawing that highlights the theme and plot (I love the overturned skull mug and the scared/dismayed looking pumpkin!) but I look at this cover and know this is going to be an entertaining and light read (which is was!) and it’s just what I’m wanting. And those covers make it so easy to spot a cozy mysteries, I could scan rows of book covers and spot them immediately.

Cozy Mysteries get such scant attention as it is in libraries and websites; very few of designate cozies as a separate subgenre, instead lumping it in with all the mysteries with generic covers of someone standing in fog holding an umbrella. And while the covers of people standing in fog are eye-catching, they do nothing to draw me in at first glance; whereas cozy mystery covers – the drawn ones, anyway – always grab my attention and before I even look at the description, I already have a good idea I’ll enjoy what’s going to be in the book.

And, as someone commented on the r/CozyMystery Discord, “I actually dock points from my reviews if the covers aren’t drawn. I totally judge a book by its cover!” and you know what? I do , too. So I’m lamenting the slow death of the cozy Cozy Mystery covers. Are we the only ones?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s